CASE Forum

Victorinox: What new tools are needed to stay at the cutting edge?

The makers of the Swiss Army Knife have emerged victorious before. But what new tools must Victorinox pull out of its pocket to meet the demands of a new century that has gotten off to a rocky start?

  • Log in
  • Share
Note: Closed forum

THE CASE

In the summer of 2009, Victorinox CEO Carl Elsener, Jr., had more on his mind than his company’s latest acquisitions. The world was mired in an economic crisis, and he wondered whether the philosophy that had seen the Swiss family company through past hardships would be enough to see it through today’s tough times.

Victorinox has come a long way from its humble beginnings. In 1884, Elsener’s great-grandfather, Karl, began selling knives out of the shop run by his mother, Victoria, who later inspired the company name. Karl delivered knives to Swiss soldiers, and by World War I, his emblematic Swiss Army Knife had become a hit. The popularity of the knives in U.S. Army stores during World War II sealed their international reputation. Soon Karl’s nifty invention, featuring everything from large and small blades to a can opener and corkscrew, was the must-have accessory of every soldier, Boy Scout and executive the world over. In fact, the distinctive Victorinox logo is so branded in public consciousness that many would be forgiven for mistaking it for the national flag of Switzerland.

Determined to be more than a knife maker, in 1979 Karl converted his one-man operation into the family-owned company we know today. Victorinox expanded dramatically throughout the ’80s, employing more than 800 people and generating millions in revenue through new product categories such as kitchen cutlery and accessories. By the early ’90s it had subsidiaries in Japan, Brazil, Chile, Hong Kong, India, Mexico, Poland and the United States. It opened its own watchmaking factory, and through various licensing agreements, began to sell travel gear and launched a fashion line and fragrances.

Then, on September 11, 2001, the terrorist attacks occurred in the United States. Authorities all around the world introduced new flight safety regulations, which forbade the carrying of knives on board planes. Those regulations had an immediate impact on Victorinox, which had been doing a swift trade in airport shops. In fact, the corporate market represented an important sales channel, as business travelers often picked up the pocket tools as corporate souvenirs. In the months immediately after September 11, Victorinox registered a 30 percent drop in sales, and the knife business has never recovered to pre-9/11 levels.

Fighting Spirit Without Sacrificing People
Victorinox had faced trying times before. After both World Wars, and during the Great Depression, there were also sharp drops in sales. Regardless of those crises, Victorinox always stuck to its creed of long-term job stability and long-term financial independence, as Elsener explains: “For the past 80 years, we didn’t dismiss any employee due to economic reasons. We always grew organically, avoiding external debt and remaining independent from the banks as much as possible.”

In order to avoid firing employees, the company put a freeze on hiring, canceled overtime and reduced shifts by 15 minutes. Employees were encouraged to take any vacation time they had accumulated. Top managers visited other companies in the region and lent 80 workers to them temporarily. Victorinox also accelerated investments in new products and markets to decrease dependence on one star product and sales channel.

In 2008, after a century of exclusive cooperation with Victorinox, the Swiss Army invited tenders for 75,000 new soldier’s knives. “With a fighting spirit and a clear objective of retaining that order, we got down to work,” says Elsener. Though Victorinox won the bid, it underscored that nothing was guaranteed.

At the end of the second quarter of 2009, Victorinox was going through an integration process after acquiring Swiss Army Brands, its North American distributor, and Wenger, a Swiss competitor. This involved implementing a differentiated brand strategy in all product categories around the world.

The questions before the board concerned whether and how the culture and values at headquarters should be applied to other branches and offices around the world. There were also concerns that outsourcing production to China could tarnish the brand image, which is synonymous with Swiss quality. Furthermore, its expanded portfolio now puts Victorinox in competition with more established companies such as TAG Heuer and Samsonite.

As Victorinox prepared to mark its 125th anniversary, Elsener wondered how it could juggle this complex list of demands while staying true to its progressive HR commitments: low turnover, a 5:1 ratio between the highest paid and average worker salary, profit sharing for all employees, preference to promote from within, union representation, private pension benefits, and flexible family and children allowances. Would the old philosophy once again carry them through? What new tools must Victorinox pull out of its pocket?

WHAT I WOULD DO

Fernando, Becerra
May 19, 2010 23:08:10

Estamos en presencia de una empresa con una marca consolidada y de gran éxito que empieza a agotar su modelo de negocio, ya no consigue crecer de manera orgánica y emplea estrategias de crecimientos en nuevos productos y mercados.
La reducción de márgenes provoca la necesidad de integrarse verticalmente hacia delante y ganar cuota de mercado a costa de comprar competidores, además de deslocalizalizar factores productivos para ser más competitivos. Por lo tanto, vemos el principio del fin de la filosofía de victorinox en cuanto a crecimiento.
Por otra parte, las integraciones entre empresas de diferentes culturas implican numerosos retos, es habitual que las empresas mayormente progresistas corrompan empresas acostumbradas a peores condiciones de trabajo, con las consecuentes problemas de motivación.
Por eso mismo se propone que Victorinox introduzca un sistema de dirección por objetivos incentivando a los trabajadores y vehiculando estas con la consecución de los objetivos estratégicos fijados po la dirección a varios niveles de la empresa:
-Matriz
-División
-Departamento
-Personal
Los beneficios repartidos entre todos los trabajadores guardarían relación con el desempeño de cada nivel, intentando desminuir el rango salarial evitando retribuir en exceso la antiguedad. El variabilizar los salarios permite amortiguar situaciones en las que los resultados no sean los esperados, y gestionar los cambios en una compañia.
Por otra parte es necesario potencar la productividad y eficiencia para poder mantener la flexibilidad laboral.

> EDITED ENGLISH TRANSLATION FOLLOWS: This is a company with a well-established, highly successful brand, whose business model is starting to wear thin. As it is no longer seeing organic growth, it is applying growth strategies with new products and markets. The erosion of margins necessitates vertical integration, gaining market share by buying out competitors, and offshoring production to become more competitive. This could mark the end of the Victorinox philosophy. Meanwhile, integrating companies from different cultures poses numerous challenges. Progressive companies tend to corrupt companies accustomed to inferior working conditions, leading to motivation issues. I suggest Victorinox introduce a management-by-objectives system, which provides incentives for workers to achieve the strategic aims set by upper management at various levels of the company: headquarters, divisions, departments, staff. The benefits, divided among all employees, would be related to performance at each level, trying to reduce the salary range by avoiding excessive remuneration for longevity. Varying wages helps to mitigate situations in which the expected results are not achieved, and to manage changes within a company. Productivity and efficiency should also be bolstered in order to maintain work flexibility.

Alfredo, Pera
May 21, 2010 05:30:33

Se puede desarrollar una operación rentable en base a la cultura y a enfocarse en la misión. La fortaleza debe buscarse internamente en la gente comprometida, agradecida y motivada, no asustada. También externamente en la extensión y fortaleza de la marca. Sin embargo, hay que vincular lo interno y lo externo mediante eficaces procesos productivos, logísticos y comerciales. La empresa va en busca de un mercado global y deslocado, compitiendo en varios segmentos y categorías. Después del 11-S el mercado ya ha sido descremado y hay que avanzar al mercado juvenil y digital, a las tribus urbanas afectas a las Harley Davidson y al BB y al iPhone.
Cabe una pregunta: ¿comercialmente vale más el nombre confundido con el de amigos de Asterix o la imagen confundida con la bandera suiza?

> EDITED ENGLISH TRANSLATION FOLLOWS: The company is seeking a global, delocalized market by competing in several segments and categories. Following 9/11, the market has already been skimmed, and it is time to delve into the young, digital market, and target the urban tribes with their love of Harley-Davidsons, BlackBerrys and iPhones. Strength must be found internally, from people who are committed, appreciative, motivated and unafraid, but also externally, in the brand’s extension and strength. Which raises the question: what’s worth more, commercially speaking, a name mistaken for the friends of Asterix, or an image mistaken for the Swiss flag?